Huel, Macros and the Quiet Theft of Your Energy
The new "liquid food" looks like progress. It is the same old trick in a beige bottle. Here is the science of energy, focus and why food is meant to build you up, not reduce you to a spreadsheet.
Picture the scene. A man in a fleece gilet stands at his kitchen island at 7:42am, shaking a beige bottle like he is mixing concrete. Inside, 400 calories of oat flour, pea protein, sunflower oil, flavourings, gums and a sprinkle of synthetic vitamins. He drinks it in ninety seconds. He calls it breakfast. He calls it optimised. By 3pm he is staring at a spreadsheet wondering why his brain feels like a wet sock.
Welcome to the era of liquid food. Welcome to Huel.
Huel is a British meal-replacement company founded in 2015. Revenue hit £254 million in its tenth year of trading, profits jumped 40 percent, and Danone has just tabled a takeover offer worth roughly €1 billion. Close to a million active customers. It is marketed as nutritionally complete convenience for busy professionals. What it actually is, biologically, is an ultra-processed shake with a vitamin label slapped on the side. And it is quietly draining the energy of a generation of high-performers who think they are doing the smart thing.
The Macro Trap
Someone hands you a number. 180 grams of protein. 220 of carbs. 70 of fat. Off you go. You hit those numbers most days. You feel virtuous. You also feel exhausted, foggy and oddly flat by mid-afternoon, and you cannot work out why.
Here is why. You have been given macros and no understanding of nutrients, digestion or food matrix. That is not a diet. That is a spreadsheet with a flavour sachet.
30 grams of protein from wild salmon is not the same as 30 grams of protein from a chocolate-flavoured shake. Both hit your tracker the same way. One delivers omega-3 fatty acids, B12, selenium, iodine and the structural fats your brain is built from, wrapped in a food matrix your gut evolved to recognise. The other delivers isolated protein, emulsifiers, sweeteners and a long list of things you cannot pronounce, blitzed into a slurry your body has no template for.
Same macros. Completely different biology. Completely different afternoon.
The RCT That Should Have Ended This Conversation
In 2019, Kevin Hall and his team at the US National Institutes of Health ran the first proper randomised controlled trial on ultra-processed food. Twenty adults lived on a metabolic ward for four weeks. Two weeks on an ultra-processed diet. Two weeks on a minimally processed diet. The two diets were matched, calorie for calorie, for protein, fat, carbohydrate, sugar, salt and fibre. Macros were identical. Participants could eat as much or as little as they wanted at each meal.
On the ultra-processed diet, people spontaneously ate around 500 calories more per day and gained roughly 0.9 kg in two weeks. On the minimally processed diet they ate less and lost weight. Same macros. Same fibre on the label. Wildly different biology. The food itself was driving the behaviour. (Hall et al., Cell Metabolism, 2019.)
Read that again. When the only thing that changed was how processed the food was, people overate by half a thousand calories a day without noticing. Your appetite, your hormones and your brain are not running on the macro panel. They are running on the food.
Now ask yourself which side of that trial your shake sits on.
What A Huel Actually Does To You
Open a pouch and you are looking at oat flour, pea protein isolate, brown rice protein, ground flaxseed, sunflower oil powder, MCT powder, sucralose, xanthan gum, a vitamin and mineral premix and a flavour system. NOVA, the food classification system used in nutrition research, places this squarely in group four. Ultra-processed.
Here is what your body experiences when you drink it.
No chewing. Chewing triggers the cephalic phase of digestion, your saliva, your gastric acid, your pancreatic enzymes, your satiety hormones. Liquid calories blunt that whole signalling cascade, which is one of the leading explanations for why people on ultra-processed diets in the Hall trial unconsciously over-ate by around 500 calories a day.
No food matrix. Real oats are a structure. Pulverised oat flour is dust. The same starch hits your bloodstream faster, spikes glucose harder, and pulls insulin up with it. You feel sharp for forty minutes and flat for the next three hours.
Synthetic micronutrients. The label looks impressive because it lists 27 vitamins and minerals. The bioavailability of synthetic folate, synthetic B12 cyanocobalamin, magnesium oxide and zinc oxide is a fraction of what you get from food. Your body knows the difference even if your tracker does not.
Emulsifiers. A growing body of work, including the French NutriNet-Santé cohort of over 100,000 adults (Sellem et al., PLOS Medicine, 2024), has linked higher intakes of emulsifiers such as carrageenans and mono- and diglycerides of fatty acids to increased cancer risk, and animal and in-vitro studies on emulsifiers like polysorbate 80 and carboxymethylcellulose suggest disrupted gut barrier function and altered microbiome composition. Around 90 percent of your serotonin is produced in the gut. Inflame it and your mood, focus and sleep all take the hit.
You are not eating a meal. You are drinking an industrial formulation that hits your tracker beautifully and your biology badly.
Adenosine, Or Why You Hit A Wall At 3pm
Every time a cell in your brain uses energy, it breaks down a molecule called ATP. One of the by-products is adenosine. Adenosine builds up across the day and binds to receptors in the brain that effectively tell you, slow down, you have done enough thinking, go and rest.
That feeling of fog at 3pm is adenosine doing its job. Caffeine works by blocking those receptors. It does not remove the adenosine. It just hides it. When the caffeine wears off, all the adenosine that has been stacking up floods the receptors at once. That is your 5pm crash.
Now layer in poor nutrition. If your mitochondria are short of B vitamins, magnesium, CoQ10 precursors and the structural fats they need, every unit of energy you produce is more expensive. You generate adenosine faster. You feel tired sooner. You reach for caffeine harder. You sleep worse. You wake up with a sleep debt and start the cycle again.
A blood-sugar spike from a fast-digesting shake at 8am sets the timer on this beautifully. You will be reaching for the kettle by ten. No macro target on earth fixes that. Only real nutrients, eaten slowly, in a real food matrix, do.
Food Drives Your Hormones, Not Just Your Physique
Every meal is a hormonal instruction. Insulin. Glucagon. Leptin. Ghrelin. Cortisol. GLP-1. PYY. Thyroid hormones. Testosterone. Dopamine. Serotonin. They all respond, directly or indirectly, to what you put on the plate, when you ate it, how processed it was, and what nutrients came along for the ride.
Eat a high-sugar or fast-digesting liquid breakfast on an empty stomach and you spike insulin, crash glucose, raise cortisol to bring it back up, and prime yourself for cravings, irritability and poor decisions for the next four hours. Eat 30 to 40 grams of real protein with fat, fibre, polyphenols and a bit of slow carbohydrate and you blunt that curve, support steady dopamine, and walk into the morning calm.
Chronic under-eating, especially of fats and whole-food carbohydrates, suppresses thyroid output and lowers testosterone. You feel cold, tired, weak and uninterested in things you used to care about. People often call this "discipline". It is closer to slow self-starvation dressed up as a diet plan.
Ultra-processed food, including beige shakes, also trains your dopamine system to expect a hit from every meal. Real food starts to feel boring. Your motivation system is no longer built around training, work or ambition. It is built around the next snack.
Food Is Meant To Build You Up
This is the bit nobody is selling you, because you cannot put it in a subscription pouch.
Food is meant to build you up. Not strip you down. Not hit a number. Not save you twelve minutes on a Tuesday. Build you up.
Build the muscle that carries you up a mountain at 50. Build the neurotransmitters that give you a clear head in a hard meeting. Build the hormones that drive your sex life, your sleep and your ambition. Build a gut lining robust enough to handle stress, travel and the occasional decent bottle of wine. Build a microbiome diverse enough to make the short-chain fatty acids that quietly run your immune system.
You should walk away from a meal feeling more capable, not lighter. More focused, not flatter. Warmer, not colder. If you finish meals wondering why you still feel rough, the issue is rarely your willpower or your macro split. It is the quality, the variety and the realness of what is going in.
At Evolve and Perform we do not look at humans as a weight on a scale or a row in a tracker. We look at the whole system. Sleep, stress, gut, hormones, mitochondria, training, light, breath, relationships, the lot. Because that is what a human actually is. The macro spreadsheet was always a tiny corner of the picture, and the liquid-food crowd has shrunk it further.
A Better Way To Eat For Energy And Focus
Stop chasing the perfect macro split and the most convenient bottle. Start asking better questions.
- Did this meal come from a plant, an animal or a factory? Aim for the first two on the vast majority of plates.
- What nutrients did it actually deliver? Not just protein and carbs, but minerals, omega-3s, polyphenols, fibre and live microbes.
- How many different plants have I eaten this week? Aim for 30. Herbs, spices, seeds and nuts count.
- Did I front-load real protein and fat in the morning, chewed and digested, so my hormones and blood sugar are steady?
- Am I fuelling my brain across the day, or trying to caffeinate my way past adenosine?
- Did I actually enjoy what I ate? If the answer is no, the diet will not last and your nervous system will not thank you.
The Bottom Line
Macros are a useful tool. They are a terrible philosophy. A vitamin label on a beige bottle is not nutrition. It is marketing.
The Hall trial showed that even when you match macros perfectly, ultra-processed food makes humans overeat, gain fat and feel worse. Your shake is not exempt because the founder wears a fleece and talks about sustainability.
You do not need another shiny label. You need the tools. Real protein, real fats, real plants, real variety, properly hydrated, chewed, eaten with some pleasure, ideally with people you like. Understand that every meal is a message to your hormones, your gut and your brain, not a row in a spreadsheet or a tick on a subscription.
Get that right and the energy, the focus and the drive come back on their own. No bottle required.
Want this dialled in for your week?
If you are hitting your macros and still feeling flat, foggy and unmotivated, a discovery call is the fastest way to work out what is actually going on with your nutrients, hormones and energy.
Book a Discovery Call